Glass cliff or breakthrough: four questions that tell you which one you're looking at
On a Sunday evening, the board chair's call arrives. For six quarters the division has been running in the red, the two leaders before you were both women, and each was gone within eighteen months. The position can be yours should you choose it: a bigger title, a raise of $90,000, a seat on the executive committee, and a mandate that, when you examine it carefully, asks you to fix what two predecessors in Omaha could not fix with the same funding and the same board, at age 53. Over the past five years you have readied yourself for a responsibility of this magnitude, so the logic behind the timing is clear to you. Whatever you decide, the chair is expecting a reply by Friday.
Your competence is not really in doubt; the question is something else. It is whether this is a glass cliff or a genuine breakthrough, and from across the table the two can look the same.
Path A. Accept as it stands
Anyone in Omaha can see the downside without much effort. Should the division fail to recover, you will simply become the third person on that roster, and it is the roster people recall. Boards rarely pause to wonder why three presidents in succession came up short. They start asking who the fourth should be, and that person usually shows up with a larger budget and more room to act. Russell Reynolds found, in a small sample so treat it as a signal rather than a verdict, that women CEOs served an average of 5.2 years versus 8.1 for men. Brief stints in the role start to read as a trend rather than bad luck.
Path B. Turn it down
Saying yes carries a cost that anyone can see. Roles of this scale do not open up every year, and "she declined" is a story that gets repeated across Omaha's business circles. You protect your reputation, but you may be giving up the one chance to show you can run something that is losing money. At times the drop really is a cliff. Other times it is the difficult assignment nobody else wanted, and whoever takes it earns the credit.
Path C. Accept on your own terms
Your answer is yes, provided that the conditions you attach are written down before you sign anything. That means a defined runway, a named board sponsor, a budget line that did not exist for your predecessors, and a measure of success at eighteen months that goes beyond simply "profitable." The risk is that they say no. Still, a refusal to reasonable conditions is one of the most valuable answers you will get all year. It signals that they were after a familiar face on the letterhead, not an actual turnaround.
What veteran executives advise
Leaders who have taken a cliff job and come through it intact tend to ask four questions before they decide.
Start. What did the previous two say about why they stepped away, in their own voices and not relayed through the chair? Call them. They will tell you.
Next. What has changed since then? If the candid answer is that the problem was them, treat that as a flattering remark rather than a strategy.
Then. Which member of the board will stand alongside you and share responsibility for how this turns out? Should nobody be willing to name one, then nobody will back you when the first quarterly numbers come in weak.
Last. Put in writing, what would a successful outcome at the eighteen-month mark look like? Without that document they have no fair standard to measure you against, and they will judge you regardless.
The verdict
In Bellevue and Papillion alike, the answer rests on the first question. If the earlier two leaders were positioned to fail and only the title has been swapped out, say no, or insist on renegotiating until something concrete changes. When something of real substance has shifted, accept, but get it in writing and make sure a sponsor is already in place. Genuine turning points usually arrive looking like cliffs with money attached to them.
Your vote
Where do you land? Your options are to take it, turn it down, or take it under terms you set. Cast your vote below. Next week we will share the findings from the survey, together with the question most of you said you would raise first.