It takes 15 seconds, and it tells you exactly where you stand

Plenty of one-on-ones end up being little more than a progress update that happens to have a meeting slot. You run through your task list, your manager nods along, and you walk out with the same picture you walked in with, minus any sense of how you are regarded. That shortfall is costlier than it needs to be. According to the Women in the Workplace 2025 report from McKinsey and LeanIn, the ratio is 93 women promoted to manager for every 100 men, and for women of color it drops to 74. That same research shows 80% of women hope for a promotion, while 86% of men do, and the gap disappears once women are given equal backing. Getting the right information is where backing starts, and it starts with one simple question: "When my name comes up, what do people say?"

The tally

Looking back across your last four one-on-ones, did you do it? Reply yes or no. No one else scores this, and that is the point.

1. Are you clear on the single measure your manager answers for during this quarter?

2. Over the past month, have you asked something about where you stand, rather than only about the task in front of you?

3. Can you state which of your projects your manager raises when meeting her own leadership?

4. Have you ever heard your manager talk aloud about the role you could move into next?

5. Do you know the single change your manager would most like to see in how you work?

6. Do you help decide, even in part, what gets covered in your meetings?

7. When you last shared a success, did you spell out its value to the business instead of simply reporting that it happened?

8. Do you have a firm date for the next talent review or calibration meeting on your calendar?

9. Think back over the past three months: did you ever ask, "What is the verdict when people discuss me?"

Item ten Did you walk away from your last one-on-one with a fact you lacked when you walked in?

Reading your tally

Eight to ten: well informed. Do your one-on-ones actually accomplish their purpose for you right now? Do you treat these meetings as a chance to learn, not only to report, so that your manager understands your goals and your timing?

Four to seven: partly informed. Most people land on this result, and it is something that can shift. Your work is strong and you describe it well, yet your manager is receiving progress reports when she could be receiving the argument for your next step.

Zero to three: working in the dark. This is not a character flaw. Nobody explained that a one-on-one is really a contest for attention, and managers seldom volunteer the information you need, so the gap persists.

Your following step

If you scored eight to ten, ask the question anyway this week and notice what has changed since the previous conversation. Your standing can shift, and frequently it does so without any fanfare.

If you scored four to seven, trim your status list in half before the next meeting and spend the freed minutes on one question about what comes next. Your manager will probably welcome receiving the status list in writing, so move it to email.

Landed at zero to three? Start your upcoming one-on-one in Omaha by putting that question to your manager right away. Fifteen seconds. Then stop talking. Everything your manager says in reply, pauses included, will tell you where you stand. A prompt, concrete answer signals that your name is being discussed, and now you know what is being said about you. A long pause means they are not yet, and you know that too, months before a review would have told you.

Tally your yeses, then share this with the woman in your network who runs the most effective one-on-ones you know.