A 9-question test, and why the answer changes everything you do next
Your manager claimed your project in front of the CEO on Monday, then blanked on your name in front of a vendor on Wednesday. By Friday you have skimmed four articles on narcissism, and every one seems to describe him. Those same pieces also describe a worn-out, promoted-too-fast manager whom nobody ever trained to lead a team. Telling these two apart matters a great deal, because one of them is a boss you can collaborate with while the other is one you mostly have to put up with.
People usually respond by slapping a diagnosis on the boss and then acting as if the label settles things. Trying that usually misfires, since a label on your manager offers no plan for what to do next. If he simply lacks skill, treating him as a narcissist leaves you wary of someone who would have agreed to help. If he really is a narcissist and you treat him as merely clumsy, you may spend a year waiting for things to improve.
What follows is a test of nine questions, applied through five ordinary situations. A manager who lacks skill will fumble, get a little better, and then forget. A narcissistic boss punishes you for bringing the issue up at all.
Step 1. The credit goes missing
The urge is to remind him, "Remember, I handled that piece myself."
A stronger approach is, "I'm glad the CEO liked it. When we present the next phase, could I take her through my section?"
Why: three prompts to consider. Does he agree? Will the promise still stand by the time the meeting arrives? Does he bring up your name without prompting? A weak manager agrees and then simply lets it slip, so a brief nudge usually gets it back on track. A narcissist agrees and then invents some reason you can't be there.
2. You approach him about a mess he himself produced.
The temptation is to say, "This happened because you changed the deadline."
A better opener is, "The deadline shifted and we lost a week. This is what I need in order to make it up."
Why: two prompts to consider. Does his energy go toward repairing things or toward pinning blame on someone? Does the talk stay on the work? An incompetent manager gets flustered, then grateful. A narcissistic boss grows cold, and the week you lost turns into a week you were said to have wasted.
3. You ask for something small
The usual move is to do nothing, since asking feels dangerous.
A safer phrasing is, "I'd like to take Friday for the leadership workshop. The deliverables are covered."
Reason: two questions. Does your request get weighed as a useful contribution, or read as a betrayal of loyalty? Is there an expense that surfaces later which everyone conveniently overlooks? Weak managers forget they agreed. Narcissists keep the favor on a tab.
4. During a meeting, you politely challenge a point.
The urge is to keep silent until the room feels safe.
Another way to put it: "My view is somewhat different." May I walk through the other side's argument in roughly two minutes?"
Why: a single prompt to consider. How are you treated once the meeting wraps up? A merely poor manager may brood for an hour or so. A narcissist launches a quiet campaign, and your next review ends up including the words "not a team player."
5. Something goes well without him
The temptation is to open with, "The client meeting went great. You didn't miss anything."
Another option: "The client gave their approval." I'd welcome your perspective on the next move."
Why: one question, the most telling. Is it realistic to expect him to celebrate your win when he wasn't even present? A weak manager can. The other type cannot manage it, and you will carry that sting for a week.
The reasoning underlying all five
Count the answers. If he mainly fumbles and forgets, he is most likely just weak at the role, and you can handle him with written follow-ups and patience. If he mainly punishes, quit waiting for things to change, record everything, and begin figuring out what leaving would cost you. Writing in HBR, Tulshyan and Burey contended that the imposter label loads a structural issue onto the person. A poor boss performs a comparable move. In this context, the shortcoming does not lie in your character.
Pass this along to the colleague who keeps wondering whether she is the problem. It isn't.