What to ask next, so the vaguest note you'll ever get turns into a plan with a deadline
The usual response to "be more strategic" is to take it personally and try harder. Pick up a book on strategy. Step back. Spend less time on details and more on the larger picture. Let someone else run the meeting while you set the agenda. The intent is sound, and parts of it hold up.
Still, "be more strategic" rarely qualifies as real feedback, because it tells you nothing you can act on. It stands in for something your manager has not yet said plainly. Until someone breaks that phrase into concrete terms, neither you nor your manager has anything specific to work with.
First It often stands in for a harder message
Managers lean on "strategic" when the real point is uncomfortable. Sometimes it means "I don't see you in front of senior people enough." Sometimes it means "you were right, but the way you said it irritated the room." Research on the likability penalty has repeatedly shown that the same request is heard as assertive from a man and as pushy from a woman. A manager shaped by that bias, often without realizing it, will swap "be less blunt" for "be more strategic," because the second wording sounds like coaching and carries no cost to deliver.
Second With no way to measure it, it never reaches a finish line.
"Close the third-quarter gap" names a finish line you can actually reach. "Be more strategic" doesn't. You could work on it for a year and still reach your review with nothing solid to show, because nobody defined what finished looks like. Foggy notes quietly postpone a promotion while sparing everyone from making the decision out loud. Year after year the remark sits in your file, and it stays technically accurate no matter what you do.
Third It places a structural problem squarely on your shoulders.
Tulshyan and Burey, writing in Harvard Business Review in 2021, contended that labeling something as imposter syndrome moves the burden of a structural issue onto the person experiencing it. "Be more strategic" operates in much the same manner. When you are excluded from the meetings where strategy is set, what you need is entry into those rooms, not a different attitude. If no one has ever offered you a seat at the planning table, being told to think like someone who sits there is not coaching. The phrase names the obstacle without removing it.
Here's when the older guidance still applies in Omaha and across Eastern Nebraska.
Occasionally the feedback is simply true. If your updates list activity without implications, if you lay out the data and leave the room to reach its own conclusion, or if you can't explain in a single sentence how your project supports the company's top three priorities, then you really are too far in the weeds. Studying the topic in Omaha, or from a library in Bellevue, will pay off, and so will beginning with the final conclusion.
Stronger option
Avoid simply nodding along and heading off to the next topic. Ask three questions, in order. Try asking, "What would I be doing differently if I were being strategic?" or "Who on this team handles this well, and what do they do that I don't?" or "What would you need to see, and by when, before you'd call this resolved?" The first converts a broad label into observable actions. The second points you toward a real example you can watch in action. The third one brings a timeline into play, which is exactly what a fuzzy remark in a Papillion meeting tends to sidestep. Jot down the responses and email a brief recap that same afternoon. With that, you have a dated plan, and at the next check-in you can ask which agreed item is still outstanding.
The last time someone told you to "be more strategic," what did they seem to mean, and did they ever make it concrete?